Scotia Capital prefers CP (T.CP) shares over rival CN (T.CNR) due to better growth prospects

Stockhouse Editorial
1 Comment| March 17, 2014


Scotia Capital Inc. analysts Turan Quettawala has offered some “takeaways’’ from the recent TPM Conference (trans-Pacific and global container shipping) in California, including reduced first quarter estimates for both Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd.  (TSX: T.CPStock Forum) and Canadian National Railway Co. (TSX: T.CNR, Stock Forum) due to weather.

The reduction in first quarter estimates was significant as volumes are weak for both rails, Quettawala wrote in a research report.

“However, on a full year 2014 basis, this was offset by improved volume expectations in the second quarter,” the analyst said.

“Many customers have been vocal about lack of cars, which suggests that there is pent-up volume. As such, there may even be some volume-related upside to our first quarter estimates for both rails if the weather improves faster.’’

Quettawala went on to say that for CP, the recently announced buyback announcement also helped EPS estimates for full year 2014 and 2015.

“We believe that in a positive economic environment, both rails are likely to outperform the market with relatively low risk,’’ he wrote.

“CP remains our preferred pick, based on better growth prospects. Also, we believe there is upside to consensus estimates over the next 12 to 18 months. We would be buyers of CP shares on any quarter-related weakness.”

Scotia has reduced CP’s earnings per share to $1.39, based on weather-related weakness.  “We believe the consensus estimate for Q1 will likely come down over the next few weeks as the volume picture becomes clearier,’’ Quettawala said.

Scotia has cut its 2014 IPS estimate for CNR by 1% to $3.40 from $3.43 as the investment firm expects volumes to recover materially in the second quarter. The Q1 EPS estimate now stands at $0.62.

Quettawala has set a one-year stock price target of $176 for Canadian Pacific, which traded Monday at $171.14. He has set a one-year-target for CN at $65. The stock traded Monday at $62.63.

Tags: INDUSTRIALS RAILROADS

Rate this article
0 stars
v
Usefulness

Clarity

Credibility

Comments

GaiusOctavius
If played right, C.WOF - Woulfe Mining could become a MAJOR over the next decade and beyond, but they've got to get this Sangdong Mine running first! Advice (if you are willing to take it): 'Be like Warren Buffett or Ned Goodman', build a large position, then sit for a long time.... Cheers!
2 stars
March 18, 2014
Rate this comment
0 stars
v
Usefulness

Clarity

Credibility

Leave a Message

You must be logged in to access this feature.