Ahh...yes, attack the person, not the argument. I see it so often on the board.
So the reserves have been booked for all of their producing formations? And you know what the replacement ratio and decline rates are?
You can't assign a value to PTA based soley on initial production testing. You can say it should be 40, 50, 60, 80, 1.00 all you want, but it's meaningless.
PTA's "archives" won't help me. That made me chuckle.