Subtle...I can't recall whether he thought MCP was wonderful or Lynas, but he did at least one of them, which I suspect he has no wish to bring up in relation to his expertise, and he has always failed to see any thing very positive about GWMG, it's management, or it's accomplishments.  I guess he was not getting any fun out of whatever he has been doing lately, and decided to assume leadership of the rabble here.