These commodity stocks are on the brink of disaster

Investors in natural gas stocks have lost their minds. They're about to lose their wallets, too...

There's a major wipeout coming in the natural gas business. North America has too many natural gas producers. The industry needs a major cleaning out. The most inefficient, high-cost producers must fold. This will bring supply and demand back into balance.

Low prices are the market's mechanism for culling the weak players. Four weeks ago, natural gas prices hit a seven-year low of $2.50 per thousand cubic feet. But so far, nothing's happened. No player wants to cut production when they've invested so much money developing it. "Getting $3 is better than nothing," they think. "Better to pump out more now before it falls even farther."

In the last four weeks, gas has jumped above $4 and is closing in on $5. With higher prices, production is growing. According to industry researcher Baker Hughes, the number of rigs drilling for natural gas in the United States has gained in nine of the last 10 weeks. Meanwhile, the oversupply of gas is so great, we've almost run out of room to store it.

The Energy Information Administration says U.S. natural gas inventories rose again last week. They are now a just a chip shot from the record high hit in November 2007. Natural gas storage in producing regions – including Texas, Louisiana, and Oklahoma – already reached a record high last month.

Aubrey McClendon, CEO of Chesapeake Energy, the largest independent gas producer in America, figures America's natural gas industry will fill up all available storage by the end of the year. There'll be "involuntary curtailments," he says.

This chart compares UNG, the exchange-traded fund (ETF) for natural gas (in black), with XNG, the AMEX index of natural gas producers (in blue). XNG is an index of natural gas producers like Chesapeake, Devon, Anadarko, and Apache.

In the last two years, the price of natural gas has fallen almost 70%, yet natural gas stocks are still trading at almost the same prices. In other words, investors in natural gas stocks have totally ignored the huge collapse in natural gas prices.

And get this...

This chart shows the AMEX oil producer index (in black) cast against the AMEX natural gas producer index (in blue). The AMEX oil producer index contains names like ConocoPhillips, Chevron, and Hess.

Natural gas stocks have thrashed oil stocks over the last nine months, even though the price of oil gained 60% over this time, while the price of natural gas lost 13%.

The guillotine is about to fall on natural gas production. And I can't see any reason for this strength in natural gas stocks. My only conclusion: Investors in natural gas stocks are living in la-la land. The dream ends when storage runs out or gas prices fall back down again.

Aggressive traders should immediately short high-cost, speculative natural gas stocks. Conservative investors should wait for the storm to pass. They'll be able to pick up the highest-quality producers at bargain prices. I expect some of these companies will be paying 20%-30% dividend yields in the aftermath.

I'll let you know when the time comes.

Read more Stockhouse articles by Tom Dyson

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Tom Dyson, DailyWealth

DailyWealth is free daily investment newsletter focused on the best contrarian investment opportunities in the world. We write with a simple belief in mind: You don't have to take big risks to make big money with your investments. http://www.dailywealth.com/

leave a comment

print email

Comments

frankseles

Bailout risk: $23.7 trillion? More like $3 trillion TARP's overseer has struck a chord with his estimate that the government has committed $23.7 trillion to rescue the economyhttp://money.cnn.com/2009/07/22/news/economy/bailout_watchdog_barofsky/index.htm

hardlesson

to further my comments..I am not saying natural gas stocks are going to do the same, as i right this the natural gas spot price is collapsing...I am only saying that for gas to not recover a huge change in fundamentals has to occur...

hardlesson

look the media is starting to turn negative on natural gas...is it time to buy???The only thing that will stop natural gas from going up this winter is a huge long term shift in the fundamentals..similiar to the way it traded before 2000..I think there is just to much speculation for that to happen but we will see.

frankseles

HongKong: China boosts int'l use of yuan Investors are celebrating an incipient “recovery,” but the interventions thatwere responsible for it are sowing the seeds of a more violent contraction downthe road. The problem, quite simply, is debt. We’ve accumulated record amounts,yet many economists tell us we need more. Leading the charge is Paul Krugman. He exhorts us to borrow our way back toprosperity, but he doesn’t acknowledge that his brand of Keynesian economicsignores the consequences of debt. If you look at a chart of America’s total debtburden, he’s leading us over a cliff. (Click chart to enlarge in new window)

frankseles

Byron King: Peak Gold + Weak Dollar= $2,000+ Unemployment may be a lagging indicator, but it's lagging like an anchor chainon your boat, especially when the numbers get up in the 9% and 10% rangenationally. And then look at certain critical states. California, Michigan,Illinois, NewYork and Pennsylvania are all big, populous, busystates with lots going on and high unemployment rates. Where do you go with youreconomy when you've got that level of unemployment? Andwhat we're seeing is the nice numbers. There's a lot of ugliness behind them. Ifyou look at the shadow statistics, you may as well add 50% or 75%. You know, 10%unemployment could really be 15% or 17% if you looked at who's really notworking. Look at numbers of people applying for early Social Security ordisability. They're up 45% and more this year. These are people at the bow waveof the Baby Boom, exiting the workforce, and entering a life of governmentdependency Investors are celebrating an incipient “recovery,” but th

Stockhouse Conflict and Disclosure Policy:

Stockhouse publishing Ltd., owners and operators of Stockhouse.com, has established the following rules to ensure that there is no appearance of impropriety on the part of any Stockhouse Editorial writers ("Writers"). The content of Stockhouse Editorial articles (the "Articles") are the opinion of the Writer and any reliance on the content of these articles is at your sole risk. Our Writers are not registered investment advisors. You should not make any kind of investment decision in relation to Articles or stocks discussed in them without obtaining advice from a registered investment advisor.

Facts relied upon by our Writers are generally provided by the subject companies or gathered by our Writers from other public and/or private sources. These facts may be in error and if so, the opinions of our Writers may be materially different.

Writers may own, buy, or sell shares in public companies mentioned in their Articles, but in the Article they must prominently state their ownership position. Thus, a conflict may exist. Writers are not permitted to write Articles that attempt to benefit persons connected to the Writer, such as family or friends, except where disclosure is made in the same way as if the Writer him/herself owns stock.

Writers cannot solicit, accept, or agree to receive anything of value given or paid with the intent of influencing their Articles.

Stockhouse notifies each Writer about these rules, and we rely on the integrity of our Writers to ensure that our rules are followed.